Inmate intervention: Feds in charge of Sunset Park prison sued for ‘inhumane’ conditions during week-long power outage

No justice, no heat: Protesters gathered at the Metropolitan Detention Center in Sunset Park, on 29th Street between Second and Third avenues, the day after the New York Times first reported that more than 1,600 men incarcerated at the jail had been without heat during a week of freezing temperatures.
Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Officials at a federal Sunset Park prison violated the constitutional rights of more than 1,600 incarcerated men by forcing the inmates to endure freezing temperatures, and barring them from speaking with their lawyers, during a week-long power outage, according to a new lawsuit.

Attorneys with the Federal Defenders of New York — an independent group that defends vulnerable people accused of federal crimes — on Monday filed the suit against Feds with the Bureau of Prisons, which operates the Metropolitan Detention Center, and its warden, Herman Quay.

The suit claims conditions inside the prison are “inhumane,” and alleges that Quay and other brass at the 29th Street jail between Second and Third avenues did not move fast enough to restore heat and power after a Jan. 27 electrical fire that caused “wide-ranging power outages” resulting in “little to no heating” inside the building during some of the borough’s coldest days on record, when temperatures plunged to below 10 degrees Farenheit.

“There is a humanitarian crisis taking place at the main federal detention facility in this district,” the lawsuit reads. “They have been slow to acknowledge the problem and have not taken sufficient steps to obtain temporary supplies of electricity or heat, or to repair the damage.”

Following the fire, prison officials also cancelled legal and social visits until Feb. 4 without adequate explanations, according to the suit, which claims that Quay said the heat had “never been impacted” hours before the Federal Defenders’s attorney-in-chief visited the facility and found the inmates “wearing only short-sleeved shirts and light cotton pants” while prison staffers sported “multiple layers and scarves around their heads.”

Inmates also had no access to medical care, clean clothing, or hot food during the week-long outage, according to the suit and local pols who visited the facility amid the incident, including Councilman Jumaane Williams (D–Flatbush) and Rep. Jerrold Nadler (D–Red Hook).

The Federal Defenders filed its lawsuit in the wake of several protests at the prison after the New York Times first reported on the conditions inside it on Feb. 1.

Protesters, who included several local pols, communicated with inmates via signs and chants during the Feb. 2 and 3 rallies, and some attendees tried to force their way into the jail, only to be fended off by corrections officers shooting pepper spray,
the Times reported.

Prisons Bureau officials are now investigating the pepper-spray reports, according to an agency rep, who confirmed power was restored at the prison on Feb. 3, and claimed its heat “was operational despite the electrical outage.”

But the rep did not respond to repeated inquiries about the bureau’s definition of “operational,” only saying its leaders are conducting a “complete and thorough review of the situation in coordination with the Department of Justice.”

The Federal Defenders’s suit against the Feds came on the same day the Metropolitan Detention Center received a bomb threat from an unknown source just before 10:30 am, the Prisons Bureau rep confirmed, suspending the facility’s normal operations until around 2 pm, with legal and social visits to the prison resuming about three hours after that, the rep said.

A small group of protesters continued their demonstrations outside the prison after it received the bomb threat, banging on pots to convey their support for inmates, and hanging signs declaring “heat now” and “MDC is criminal” on a wall opposite the facility.

And the men inside the prison communicated their misery to the crowds outside it all weekend long by banging on their cell windows, and responding to questions about their conditions after activists shouted them from bullhorns, according to a protestor.

“They were saying that it’s not safe in there, and that it’s war inside,” said Thalyha Gonzalez, who said her stepfather is serving time in the prison.

Another advocate outside the prison on Feb.4 said no person should be exposed to the depraved conditions that officials allegedly forced the inmates to endure.

“Everybody looks at them as at the bottom, but at the end of the day, they’re human beings,” said Jay Heemdowdy. “Inhumane treatment should not be a form of punishment in America.”

Later that day, Sunset Park’s congresswoman blasted the incident as a violation of the prisoners’ essential rights on a conference call organized by Councilman Carlos Menchaca (D–Sunset Park), vowing she and her colleagues in Washington, DC, will demand a federal investigation into the incident.

“It’s a blatant disregard for human rights,” said Rep. Nydia Velazquez (D–Sunset Park). “The broken criminal justice system targets low-income people and people of color for disproportionate punishment and unfair treatment.”

Reach reporter Julianne McShane at (718) 260–2523 or by e-mail at Follow her on Twitter @juliannemcshane.
Updated 8:47 pm, February 6, 2019
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

Frank from Furter says:
2 points 1. Most of the people held at Sunset park and at MDC are pre-trial detainees. They are presumed innocent. 2. Tax rates are at a post WW2 low. Taxes pay for among other things the largest Military budget since WW2. You can always refuse your social security or medicare(yes I know you paid for that)
Feb. 6, 1:16 pm
Mike from Williamsburg says:
It would be nice to see the Brooklyn DA charge some of these monsters.
Feb. 6, 1:49 pm
Susan from Kensington says:
TY Frank for Furter for accurate facts rather than than Tea Party rhetoric.
Feb. 6, 1:50 pm
Henry Ford from Bay Ridge says:
I’m talking about working class people paying higher property taxes than the mayor and his buddies pay for their mansions, that they used creative means to exempt themselves from. It’s laughable how the mayor loves to spend everyone else’s money to pay for healthcare for illegals, but uses every trick in the books to keep his own money. Bridge tolls approaching $20 yet the entire infrastructure of the city is collapsing. Taxes on your paycheck stub that you need an accountant to figure out and yet NYCHA tennants haven’t had heat in years, and all the fake woke SJWs are crying about some chilly prisoners. And you all wonder why the working class flocks to Republicans.
Feb. 6, 2:23 pm
Tony from Coney says:
I know one "advocate" has a relative in the prison but how do all these Pols from Brooklyn know what the conditions are in the prison? Theirfamily members in there as well? I'll give you one reason why its not safe in prison. It's full of CRIMINALS!
Feb. 6, 3:09 pm
BDBarb from Sunset Park says:
I see that innocent until proven guilty doesn't apply to this crowd. And whatever happened to rehabilitation for those who are guilty? If it was up to some of you, we'd revert back to the days of the Spanish Inquisition and punish folk just because you have a yen for cruelty.
Feb. 6, 5:03 pm
Bella from Coney Island says:
wondering how many elected officials are going to protest against terrible condition in NYCHA? Do you know how many people were without gas or hot water in NYCHA developments? I do not see anyone screaming and protesting.
Feb. 6, 5:25 pm
Ken from Greenpoint says:
Yeah dummy, because republicans are so vested in the working class. They whisper sweet nothings to the dumb racists and get their votes. Wake up.
Feb. 6, 6:05 pm
Larry from Clinton Hill says:
Trump is my man , President Trump is the best President the USA has had in over 100 Years
Feb. 6, 6:36 pm
Frank from Furter says:
Please remember that Trump takes credit for the free them now act.
Feb. 7, 6:56 am
Low IQ says:
You can protest lack of heat in prisons as well as NYCHA. There is plenty of news about NYCHA as well as its federal monitoring. You can protest one injustice without negating another.
Feb. 8, 1:40 am

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: