In the black: New shadow study of C’Heights towers shows dim future for Botanic Garden, P’Park

Dark garden: Large development projects on Franklin Avenue will cast shadows across the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, Prospect Park, and the Jackie Robinson Playground that will linger for hours on some days, a new study shows.
Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

It’s a dark prospect.

Three towering Crown Heights developments planned to rise blocks from the Brooklyn Botanic Garden and Prospect Park will deprive those and other nearby green spaces of precious sunlight each day, according to a study commissioned by a local anti-gentrification group.

Movement to Protect the People leaders tapped private architectural firms to create digital replicas of the projects — which include one developer’s 441-foot-tall complex and another’s two 235-foot-tall towers, all three of which would be erected on Franklin Avenue between Sullivan Place and President Street — for the shadow study, which showed the structures would noticeably block rays from the Prospect Heights garden and a public playground blocks away on Montgomery Street year-round, sometimes for hours in a day.

“The shadow analysis determined that the duration and coverage of incremental shadows on the Brooklyn Botanic Garden and Jackie Robinson Playground would be significant,” said a summary of the study conducted by Manhattan-based companies SCALAR Architecture and Terreform Center for Advanced Urban Research.

On some of the longest days of the year, the taller of the two developments — builder Continuum Company’s six-tower complex at 960 Franklin Ave. — would cast an early morning shadow over the Botanic Garden that stretches all the way into Brooklyn’s Backyard, darkening parts of the green spaces for several hours, according to the study, which shows shadows covering the lawns from around 6 to 10:30 am on a test date of June 21.

Affected areas in the Botanic Garden would include greenhouses at the Steinhardt Conservancy and the Herb, Water, and Children’s gardens, and in Prospect Park, part of the zoo would be covered by the shadow.

And later that same day, the study shows the complex’s shadow would migrate to blanket the Jackie Robinson Playground for a whopping five hours, from roughly 1:00 to 6:01 pm.

The two smaller towers proposed by builder Cornell Realty Management — whose height already drew the ire of concerned Botanic Garden lovers — would also cast shadows that darken parts of the Prospect Heights growing patch for hours, according to the study’s June 21 test date, but they would not cover as much area as those cast by its bigger neighbor.

Both Continuum’s and Cornell’s projects, however, require the city to green-light upzonings on their proposed lots, where regulations currently cap buildings at seven stories or less — largely as a means of protecting the Botanic Garden’s plants and sight lines.

Garden leaders recently panned the Continuum complex, but took Cornell brass at their word last year when they said their own city-mandated shadow study of their two towers showed they would not harm any flora.

But that may be because the firm based its own study on a smaller 175-foot tower that didn’t account for rooftop bulkheads, or factor in additional building rights the developer could obtain through a city program that permits higher towers in exchange for including space for a grocery store inside them, according to a researcher who contributed to the just-released study.

“Regulations require developers to show the worst case scenario, but it chose not to,” said Andrea Johnson, who works for Terreform. “They modeled the building to make it appear less bulky, which would appear to create a less intimidating shadow.”

A rep for the green space couldn’t immediately comment on the newly released shadow study, but reiterated the need to maintain the area’s current zoning to safeguard its blooms.

“BBG strongly advocates maintaining the site’s current zoning — which now caps building height at six-to-seven stories — which was put in place, in part, to protect the garden’s conservatories from building shadows,” said Elizabeth Reina-Longoria.

Continuum bigwigs have yet to file all the paperwork required to complete the environmental-review process required for their upzoning application, but Movement to Protect the People leaders plan to use the new study’s results to challenge the findings Cornell already submitted to the city about its towers’ shadows, member Alicia Boyd said.

Reps for Cornell did not return requests for comment.

Reach reporter Colin Mixson at or by calling (718) 260-4505.
Updated 5:41 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

Andrew Porter from Brooklyn Heights says:
Those shadows are on the longest day of the year. Don't forget that in other months, with the sun lower in the sky, the shadows will be even longer.
June 29, 2018, 4:37 pm
Fort Greene from Historic Fort Greene says:
Here in Fort Greene, the buildings are built, the shadows cast and these past few days are telling.

Folk living in the towers of the large building actually block the sun, because it's too much for them. They pull down shades for much of the day while the sun is bright. What a horrible thing, since the real estate developers charge close to $10,000 a month for rents only for the sun to deliver too much for one or two folk. What a horrible catastrophe for the folk who no longer get their sun for backyard planting, social events or just enjoyment. A woman actually sold her house because she no longer received enough sun to light her garden.

For us living behind the buildings, our sun is casting shadows, creating more depression for the elderly and those who enjoy the sun.

The other day, in another borough, the sun made it's sunset in such beauty; I'd forgotten how beautiful it is to see the magnificence of nature in her summer bounty.

Please do not let greedy developers destroy the beautiful BBG for nothing but greed for some sun-hater who will just block the sun anyhow.
July 2, 2018, 1:06 am

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: