Jail break! Councilman Brad Lander makes his pitch to close Rikers Island

Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Brooklyn Paper Radio


iTunes · Stitcher · Spotify · Google Play · RSS

Close Rikers — and build smaller jails all over the place!

Yes, that’s Mayor DeBlasio’s proposal — and it is supported by Park Slope Councilman Brad Lander, who shared his controversial thoughts on Brooklyn Paper Radio on Tuesday.

“The first step (to closing Rikers Island) is criminal justice reform,” Lander said, literally toting a copy of the Council-commissioned report, “A More Just New York City: Independent Commission on New York City Criminal Justice and Incarceration Reform,” which advocates first halving the population of people awaiting trial or serving short sentences from roughly 10,000 people, then closing Rikers and moving its occupants to smaller, modern jails all over town.

Lander said Rikers has inherent problems, but bulldog Brooklyn Paper Radio co-host Gersh Kuntzman, a Daily News columnist by day, asked Lander why Rikers can’t just be fixed.

“Rikers has become a place that can’t be redeemed,” he said. “It’s so inconvenient that prisoners get no visitors, which may sound minor, but that creates an ‘out-of-sight-out-of-mind’ situation that increases violence. People are serving very short sentences, which don’t really make the community safer. There are other ways to punish people.”

Kuntzman’s co-host, Brooklyn Paper Editor Vince DiMiceli hated that answer.

“It’s a leadership issue,” he said. “A good leader could fix the problem.”

But the Park Slope Dem disagreed.

“The facilities themselves are not designed in the way that modern jails are designed,” he said. “I suppose you could build modern, safer facilities on Rikers, but you’ll still have the visitors issue. And visitors are good for inmates to get hope, but also have more eyes at the jail, which creates a culture of accountabi­lity.”

Then Kuntzman played the community card.

“How are you going to build new jails in communities across the city?” the once-legendary editor asked. “The city can’t even build a soft-ice cream stand without constant complaints from neighborhoods. No one wants jail visitors in their neighborho­ods.”

“There are ways to make facilities better from a community point of view, with ground floor retail, for example, so the community gets something of what it wants,” Lander said. “People do have an irrational reaction (to new facilities). We see it with homeless shelters, which are not actually a detriment to a community. We have a new one in my district and it’s good. We even have community meetings there. But, yes, there will be NIMBY (Not In My Back Yard) opposition.”

Lander also came under fire — from Kuntzman — for his continuing support for “participat­ory budget plan — which allows members of the community to choose where some Council money is spent.

“I elected you to make those choices, Lander,” Kuntzman said. “And if you don’t make good choices, I’ll vote you out.”

Lander said participatory budgeting — which 31 council members now use — is good for democracy.

“People get together and brainstorm,” he said. “Yeah, maybe I could say, ‘I’ll allocate the money,’ but the difference is that people come out and work together to solve problems. We need to remember that democracy is about neighbors coming together across lines of difference and making things better. Democracy is not a spectator sport — and what is happening in Washington shows what happens when we treat it like that.”

Kuntzman then accused Lander of quoting one of Kuntzman’s Daily News columns.

“See what he did there?” Kuntzman said. “He quoted me to me — being critical of me!”

Also joining the boys in studio was Ian Lockwood, whose new monthly comedy show, “Rude,” made its debut on Tuesday night at Williamsburg’s South 4th. Lockwood broke the biggest story: The show has no cover and features a regular segment where audience members are plied with free booze and then invited to play the game “Telephone.” Lander, Kuntzman, DiMiceli and Lockwood tried it out, albeit sober, and the phrase “Independent Commission on New York City Criminal Justice and Incarceration Reform” ended up as “Come to my house, take off your clothes, and participate in my budget process.”

All told, it was yet another instant classic edition of Brooklyn Paper Radio!

Brooklyn Paper radio is recorded and podcast live every Tuesday — at the convenience of its hosts and guests — from our studio in America’s Downtown and can be found, as always, right here on, on iTunes, on Mixlr, and of course, on Stitcher.

Updated 10:17 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

Deborah from Brooklyn says:
"If I wanted a public vote on budget, I’d go back to the Quaker Meeting style of government." Agree!!!
This "participatory budget" thing is a placebo for the real issues affecting our communities - a distraction - a cop out. If a school needs bathroom doors, it is the job of the Councilman to find a way to pay for them, and not have people vote about what is more important, bathroom doors or a library's Saturday hours. Both are, so find a way to fund them - that is Lander's job. His job is also to protect his communities and he copped out in Cobble Hill on the LICH ULURP opportunity so now that historic community will be trashed by inappropriate development - he should have down zoned the areas adjacent to brownstones. And so will be Boreum Hill be trashed with an inappropriately sized skyscrapper and an enlarged House of Detention. Fix Rikers and don't dump the problem of Rikers on local neghborhoods. This councilman is a fraud.
April 5, 2017, 4:28 am
Not Goish from Prospect Heights says:
Well Bullhorn Brad Lander, more like Bullspit Brad, Warren Wilhelm Jr.'s Mini-Me is at it again. Is he funding the vigilante shomrim in Borough Park again? And on the other side of this pandering out-of-towner's stuff ... funding alt-left propaganda?
April 5, 2017, 10:56 am
Fred from Brooklyn says:
Agree with Deborah. How much of our tax dollars do Brad and friends funnel to so called civic groups to keep his seat? Fix the damn schools. Fix the potholes. It's your job. Or better yet, go find another one! Term limits anyone?
April 6, 2017, 10:46 am
Jon from Windsor Terrace says:
Lander serves only Lander. No one else, which is why he voted himself a 30% salary increase last year even though his wife earns a six figure salary working for a non-profit.
Think Lander cares about the little guy - just remember that he acted like a pit bull dog in his failed attempt to force us to pay a nickel for all of our shopping bags.
When Rudy Guiliani was Mayor, he reduced Riker's prison population by having ships in all boros with smaller group of prisoners, something that could be used at a fraction of the cost of building new prisons and be used immediately for certain groups of prisoners, instead of letting prisoners, like hookers, just walk away with something similar to one getting a traffic ticket for running a stop sign.
Perhaps Lander will be challenged in the primary this year by one who runs a strong campaign and we all can get a decent councilman to represent us.
April 6, 2017, 11 am
BrooklynGersh from The WT says:
For the record, Fred, we do have term limits in the Council.
April 7, 2017, 12:14 pm
Rufus Leaking from BH says:
The only reason to close Rikers is that some Real Estate developer has their eye on waterfront property.

Closing Rikers and opening other jails around the city just moves the problem around. Remember when they wanted to turn the Brooklyn House of detention into condos? I do.

When this mayor wants to make a move like this - see who is waiting in the wings.
April 7, 2017, 6:21 pm
Robert Moses from Hell says:
One theory being bandied about is that the city wants to use it to extend the runways at LaGuardia. A worthy cause. Why didn't I think of that?
April 7, 2017, 9:52 pm

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: