Free to move about the country: Murder exoneree overjoyed, planning vacation

The Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

The latest man exonerated following a wrongful murder conviction under former district attorney Charles Hynes wants to dedicate his life to helping free innocent people in prison — but first, he is hitting the beach.

District Attorney Ken Thompson announced on Jan. 5 that he was vacating the conviction of Clinton Hill native Derrick Hamilton, who spent 20 years in prison for the 1991 shooting death of Nathaniel Cash despite his insistence that he was in Connecticut at the time of the murder. Cash’s girlfriend, the only witness, recanted her testimony, and pushed for Hamilton’s release. Now that his name is cleared, Hamilton has big plans, but on the top of his to-do list is taking a trip to Puerto Rico.

“It feels like a million pounds off my back,” Hamilton said. “I feel like I’ve been reborn.”

Cops arrested Hamilton in March, 1991, and he said that at the time he thought the whole thing would blow over once he showed he was innocent. But he never even made bail.

“I knew I didn’t do it, and I thought, ‘I can stand a couple months at Rikers,’ ” Hamilton said. “It was so depressing. You can say you’re innocent a million times, but no one is going to believe you.”

Hamilton was released in 2011, but was subject to the same restrictions as other parolees. He had to obtain permission to leave the state and inform potential employers of his status. On paper he remained a convicted killer.

Now he can move freely, and his record is officially scrubbed of any trace of the wrongful murder conviction.

When Thompson signed the documents freeing him of the murder rap and everything that came with it, Hamilton said he was overcome with emotion.

“To actually be invited in and hear him say, ‘You were right,’ was indescriba­ble,” he said. “I wanted to go up and hug the guy. It was the best day of my life.”

One of the cops who helped put Hamilton away was retired, now-disgraced detective Louis Scarcella, whose record has come under intense scrutiny by a wrongful-conviction review team assembled by Thompson, and who has seen five homicide convictions he helped secure be overturned, according to the New York Daily News.

Hamilton said he feels plenty of anger at Scarcella for putting him away in the first place, but he reserved most of his fury for Judge Edward Rappaport, who presided over his trial and multiple appeals.

“What he did was worse than Scarcella,” Hamilton said. “He had the opportunity to right what he did, but he never did. He knew Scarcella was crooked but believed him anyway. Judges who don’t uphold the Constitution should be taken off the bench.”

Thompson, whose campaign focused on alleged prosecutorial misconduct under 23-year top prosecutor Charles Hynes, said his exoneration of Hamilton and others is an attempt at restoring faith in the courts.

“Wrongful convictions ultimately destroy the lives of the people who are wrongfully convicted, as well as their families, and also do damage to the integrity of the justice system,” he said in a statement. “The people of Brooklyn elected me to ensure that justice is done and that is what my decision to vacate Derrick Hamilton’s conviction reflects.”

A longtime critic of Hynes who helped exonerate David McCallum cheered Thompson’s latest overturned conviction, his 11th since taking office, casting it as a blow against Hynes’s legacy of corruption.

“You gotta hand it to him. He’s not sweeping anything under the rug,” said John O’Hara, who Hynes once prosecuted for voting outside of his district. “All of Hynes’s convictions were bad. Nothing straight came out of that office.”

Hamilton praised Thompson, but said he is troubled that people who worked on his case and others involving Scarcella still have high-ranking jobs in Thompson’s office. Anne Gutmann, the prosecutor who relied on Scarcella’s work to put Hamilton behind bars, is still in the District Attorney’s Office, overseeing the Intake Bureau, which processes the early stages of criminal cases.

“I think he has an important task ahead of him and so far he is doing a great job,” Hamilton said. “But there are still people in this office who don’t want to see justice done, and it taints the process.”

Reach reporter Noah Hurowitz at or by calling (718) 260–4505. Follow him on Twitter @noahhurowitz
Updated 10:17 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

Tonto from Clinton Hill says:
Hynes reign of error is over.
Jan. 12, 2015, 5:35 pm
Charles from Bklyn says:
Wrongfully convicted does not equal innocent. You can be guilty, but wrongfully convicted, and have your conviction overturned. This story is one-sided. The courts rarely error so great as to be an injustice. Reign of terror? Crime is down dramtically in the last 15years. That would be considered a job well done. Of course, innocent people are convicted from time to time. We will probably never know on this case..
Jan. 13, 2015, 10:37 am
BrooklynSandy from Ft Greene says:
Now DA Thompson must investigate the Prospect Park Residence assisted living facility in which not only was prominent Civil Court Judge Phillips left to die, because of the malfeasance of the owner operator Haysha Deitsch in purporting it to be certified... the very same fraudulent tactics promoted this facility to 125 elders who were March 2014 with 90 days to get out. Forget the "aging in place" promised...the real estate owner masquerading as a health care operator wanted to develop the building...!

Eight elders remain...all over 90 years old...all are being subjected to slumlording so that Deitsch can get the $76,5000,000 he sold the building for in Jan. 2014 & push these ailing folks out on the street.

Isn't it criminal to deprive tenants of water...laundry services...clean when they are paying upwards of $4000/month ?

Isn't it criminal to allow the very same villainous self-defined arbiter of senior health care to keep harming folks at the end of their lives under our noses and not insist on accountability?

Hynes played fast and loose with Judge Phillips, sealed up his assets, declared him mentally incompetent, and via a court appointed "guardian" gutted his $10,000,000 estate and left him in the miserable hands of Prospect Park Residence where he died an appalling death.

If there was ever a case for prosecution...Prospect Park Residence is the criminal standard for accountability.

Nothing predicts future behavior as much as past impunity...DA Thompson must own this matter, with all due respect.

The victims are waiting and watching...
Jan. 13, 2015, 3:32 pm

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: