New Year’s by the sea: Ringing in 2015 in Coney Island

The Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Photo gallery

Making history: Coney Island historian Charles Denson and Amanda Deutch warm up at Boardwalk restaurant Tom’s of Coney Island before the Parachute Jump’s light show. Denson said he usually spends New Year’s in California, but came to Coney Island for the celebration.
Bundle up, boodie down: New Year’s cheer and a lot of dancing kept revelers warm on the windsweprt Boardwalk.
What a blockhead: Coney Island Circus Sideshow performer Alejandro Duboise put the crowd on pins and needles by pounding nails and even a screwdriver into his face.
I’ll have what he’s having: Sideshow performer Ray Valenz breathes fire for reveler’s entertainment.
Funglasses at night: Ruby Colladoo rang in the new year in style.
Kept his resolution: Borough President Adams alluded to a Coney’s New Year’s party since the summer. On New Year’s Eve, he led crowds in a Brooklyn cheer before lighting up the Parachute Jump for 2015.
Dropping the ball: The Parachute Jump was a perpetual light show on New Year’s Eve. A number of people reported missing the Jump displaying “2015,” because it only flashed for a spilt second.
Checkin’ in: Reporter Max Jaeger checks in to the Harbor Motor Inn at 12:49 am on New Year’s Day. The ultra-classy, harbor-side house only offers rooms at four-hour intervals during the New Year’s holiday, so Jaeger was back at 5 am for check-in round two.
Hottest sheets in town: Four-hour rooms at Harbor Motor Inn see a lot of action. Even the sheets in the non-smoking rooms get so hot that they have burn holes, as Elana Ehrenberg points out.
What a view: Our suite at the Harbor Inn Motel featured this stunning vista of the Benonhurst BJ’s.
Deals a-brewin’: Future New Year’s festivities tourists can shop local at Caesar’s Bay’s big-box stores. Check out the deals on crock pots at Best Buy.
Amped: The first wave of bathers rush toward the nearly freezing Atlantic Ocean for the Jan. 1 2015 Polar Bear Plunge in Coney Island.
Thrills and chills: Most people went all-in, splashing and playing in the surf despite freezing temperatures.
Whole lobster love: There was no shortage of characters on the beach on New Year’s Day.
Numbing: Mary Remington of Bushwick got a real shock when she jumped into the icy brine.
Heartwarming: Wesley Loden and Chris Donohey came out to cheer on their friend Faith Reaves.
No sweat: Reporter Max Jaeger makes the most of the mid-winter sun by applying some tanning oil just before the plunge.
Fish out of water: Reporter Max Jaeger, a native Floridian, emerges victorious after braving the frigid water during the 2015 Polar Bear Club’s New Year’s swim.

Could Coney Island become a New Year’s vacation destination?

Brooklynites rang in 2015 on the Boardwalk on Dec. 31 at a New Year’s Eve countdown party centered around the Parachute Jump. Borough President Adams promised that the inaugural bash would be a new annual tradition for Coney Island, and an aide suggested that the event could eventually draw tourists to sleep over in Sodom by the Sea.

“You could see people, in future years, coming here for New Year’s Eve, and staying the night for the polar plunge on New Year’s Day,” Borough Hall communications director Stefan Ringel said.

The idea of Coney Island as a year-round tourist destination really captured our newsroom’s imagination, so we put the hypothesis to the test by sending adventure correspondent Max Jaeger on an overnight trip to experience the festivities and soak up some local culture.

The first stop was the New Year’s Eve countdown on the Boardwalk, then a stay at a nearby by-the-hour-hotel — the only available accommodations — and on New Year’s Day, in a feat of truly immersive reporting, our Florida-born reporter delved into the frigid North Atlantic as part of the Polar Bear Club’s annual plunge.

New Year’s Eve

The Borough President really delivered on this one. The event was a free, all-ages fete that stimulated local business and local pride.

The head count in Steeplechase Plaza reached about 3,000, an Office of Emergency Management worker told me. Tom’s of Coney Island, Nathan’s Famous, Peggy O’Neill’s, and, yes, Dunkin’ Donuts overflowed with people at a time the amusement district would normally be a ghost town.

In lieu of bubbly, the crowd filled up on Brooklyn pride — it was a treat watching a usually restrained Councilman Mark Treyger (D–Sheepshead Bay) whip up the crowd with a frenzied “Brooklyn” chant while speakers blared Jay Z’s “Empire State of Mind.”

A DJ kept people dancing — and acted as a de facto emcee, because Adams was shuttling between New Year’s Eve engagements.

People seemed to like what the DJ was laying down, but a guy pushing play on a MacBook doesn’t cut it for me. Treyger said there should be more live entertainment from locals, and I couldn’t agree more. The plan for next year is to select live local acts through a battle-of-the-bands competition.

Of course, there were some drawbacks to partying at midnight in the middle of winter outside on the waterfront. For one, it was insanely cold. How about some propane heaters next time?

Then there were libation considerations. Tom’s was the only Boardwalk eatery open that evening, and Surf Avenue’s Peggy O’Neill’s levied a $10 cover, forcing thirsty revelers further afield for a flute of New Year’s cheer.

The biggest hiccup I saw was with the Parachute Jump’s light display — the side facing the crowded plaza failed to light up with “2015” at the decisive moment when the countdown finished, stalling at “2,” and skipping to a colored pattern instead. The post-countdown fireworks display also started a few seconds too early. But the real magic was bringing thousands of people together on the Boardwalk in 20-degree weather for a party.

If Adams keeps chipping away at this block of marble, he’ll have a real work of art in a few years.

The stay

After the festivities, my lovely assistant Elana and I took a cab to the closest hotel — the Harbor Motor Inn, 1.5 miles from the Parachute Jump on Shore Parkway and 24th Avenue. It was 12:30 am, and buses and trains were running on a Sunday schedule, so rides off of the peninsula were at a premium. We hailed a green cab on Stillwell Avenue. The driver told us his meter was broken and the ride would be $20. He dropped it to $15 when I asked if the Taxi and Limousine Commission knew his meter was broken and pretended to jot down his cab number. Price-gouging is a New Year’s tradition, and a boost to public transit would go a long way towards making New Year’s Eve in far-flung Coney Island a popular destination.

At the motel, the front desk informed us there were no overnight rooms available on New Year’s, so we booked a four-hour one — otherwise know as a hot-sheet suite.

Let’s talk amenities, because the Harbor Motor Inn was lousy with them. First, the sheets in our non-smoking suite were so hot they had burn holes — no kidding, burn holes! The bed had clearly seen a lot of action. Like an old baseball glove, it was wieldy and responsive, but had that sag in the middle that can only come from lots of wear.

A large window treated us to a majestic view of Stop & Stor’s corrugated metal wall. But the breathtaking vista went largely unnoticed, as our eyes were glued to the fabulous in-room TV, which piped out round-the-clock, uncensored, close-ups of adult situations — on channel 69, of course. We both slept surprisingly well, apart from a 5 am call from the concierge informing me that I needed to pay for another four hours or else hit the bricks.

If the Beep wants to lure tourists to Coney Island for more than a day, the novelty glasses crowd will definitely need somewhere else to stay. Some are speculating a hotel may be in the People’s Playground’s future.

The Beep said he is looking to Airbnb to house travelers and help locals pay their bills, which won’t sit well with hoteliers elsewhere in the borough, but is likely a step up from where I spent the night.

New Year’s Day

The next day, I was contractually bound to jump headlong into the frigid Atlantic Ocean for that 112-year-old Brooklyn tradition, the Coney Island Polar Bear Club’s annual New Year’s plunge.

My lovely assistant and I had some time to kill between our 9 am motel checkout and the 1 pm affront to good sense on the beach. Lucky for us, there was plenty of local shopping right outside our front door at Ceasar’s Bay, the big-box mecca of Bensonhurst, boasting a Kohl’s, a Best Buy, and a Toys ’R’ Us.

A Best Buy employee named Joe told me the store doesn’t see a lot of tourists, save the occasional road-tripper in search of a phone charger. Perhaps the zinc-nosed droves will arrive one day, but for now, New Year’s Day was quiet.

Next, it was back to the Boardwalk for a traditional pre-plunge breakfast at Tom’s of Coney Island.

A health nut named Bernarr Macfadden started the Coney Island Polar Bear Club in 1903, believing the frigid shock of mid-winter bathing conferred health benefits, club vice president Robbie Bailey told me. Given that, it seemed a bit odd that registration for the Polar Plunge consisted mainly of signing an indemnity waiver. If Macfadden was right, I was about to align my humors and boost my vitality with a mere 10-second dip, hopefully without that pesky side effect, hypothermia.

The term “polar plunge” is a non-sequitur in Florida, where I’m from, since the weather rarely dips below 80 degrees. I did take part in a New Year’s plunge once — but it was in Key West, and I broke a sweat walking back to my beach towel. So with the water temperature in Coney Island hovering around 35 degrees, I was a bit nervous.

As 1 pm approached, I armored myself in my people’s native garb: floral print trunks, a smearing of tanning oil, and the tackiest hat I could find. Then the moment came. I assembled with the hundreds of other bathers in my heat. My fellow plungers steeled their nerves, humming battle hymns for strength. I whistled my own paean — “Cheeseburger in Paradise” and started trotting to the surf.

Bathers who had already made it to the water were laughing and splashing in the icy brine. Hearing them in front of me, my salty dread mixed with crystal-clear joy. Is this what it’s like to pass into the afterlife?

My spiritual musing ended the instant I hit the water. It didn’t really hurt — more a sensory overload. Everything but my lizard brain froze. “Get out as fast as possible” became the overriding impulse. But in a triumph of human folly over survival instinct, I waded in waist-deep and submerged myself in the frigid sea. It was painless and exhilarating, and anyone on the fence should absolutely do it.

As we beat a hasty retreat toward our respective changing rooms packed with shivering, bare-bottomed Brooklynites, my lovely assistant Elana shouted to me, “We should make this a tradition!”

Reach reporter Max Jaeger at or by calling (718) 260–8303. Follow him on Twitter @JustTheMax.
Updated 10:17 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

Hix Rockett from Marine Park, Brooklyn says:
For future reference, there is a Comfort Inn and a Best Western on Emmons Avenue, in the Sheepshead Bay section of Brooklyn. They are a black apart. It's maybe 2 miles in the other direction, as opposed to the Harbor Motor Inn of Nastiness, that you decided to go for. Try one of those next time. Both will give you a view of the Bay and/or the boats in the Marina. Much better than the Stop-N-Store.
If New Year's at Coney Island becomes a grand tradition, I'm sure a hotel will open in closer proximity. But in the meantime, there's no need to make Brooklyn seem like a complete rat-hole. There are lots of other options, if you take the time to seek them out. Here's hoping next year is even better!
Jan. 5, 2015, 1:29 pm
Hix Rockett from Marine Park, Brooklyn says:
Damn autocorrect
Jan. 5, 2015, 1:29 pm
ty from pps says:
Block lives matter.
Jan. 5, 2015, 5:04 pm
Common Cents from Crown Heights says:
Next time take a black light with you in those hourly room rentals. That will be a story to write about...
Jan. 7, 2015, 8:24 am

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: