Ooze ships: Watercraft to cart sewage from Newtown Creek plant

Gloop sloop: The Port Richmond, one of three new sewage-transport boats designed to navigate the treacherous shoals of Newtown Creek.
for The Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

These boats are made for human-waste trafficking.

On Nov. 25 the city christened three new sludge boats, the vessels used to transport the refined sewage of wastewater treatment facilities, including the onion-domed plant on Newtown Creek in Greenpoint. The sludge that gives the watercraft their name is one of two byproducts of the sewage treatment process, the other being water. The new boats, costing $106 million altogether, are necessary because New York’s toilets are always flushing.

“The sludge never stops,” said Gordon Arnold, captain of the Port Richmond, one of the new boats.

To get a picture of what the sludge boats do in relation to sewage plants, imagine a drinking glass placed under a pitcher that is always pouring liquid, Arnold said.

“When that glass is full, you better have another glass there in a hurry,” he said.

When a boat is late, the city has a “sludge emergency,” Arnold added, though he declined to elaborate.

The Port Richmond and her fellow fleet members the Rockaway, and the Hunt’s Point, come custom-designed to navigate the shallow waters of Newtown Creek and the low clearance of the Pulaski Bridge. The city is decommissioning two older boats and keeping another, so the fleet will soon total four. Each of the new vessels takes six people to operate and can carry as many as a million gallons of muck.

Unlike their predecessors, the new boats can load sludge directly from the Newtown Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant, nearly a mile upstream at the end of Humboldt Street. The old boats stopped at the mouth of the fetid inlet to drain an 800,000-gallon storage tank on shore, connected by pipeline to the plant. Now the tank, at the foot of Dupont Street, has been dismantled to make way for the Greenpoint Landing mega-development and an expansion of Newtown Barge Park.

The Department of Environmental Protection estimates that its boats transport 1.2 billion gallons of sludge each year. Of the city’s 14 wastewater treatment plants, eight are equipped to separate the liquid in the sludge from the solid, a process known as dewatering. The other six plants must ship their goop to those eight. Newtown Creek’s plant is the biggest in the city, with sewage coming in from more than a million people in Williamsburg, Bushwick, Bedford-Stuyvesant, Greenpoint, and lower Manhattan. It does not dewater, so its sludge gets shipped to Wards Island.

At Wards Island the goop goes into a centrifuge, where it is spun until the separation occurs. The solid, a black-dirt-like substance called “cake,” is handed off to a private contractor for disposal, in landfills and in abandoned mines in Pennsylvania. The nitrogen-rich liquid, or centrate, is eventually released as clean water.

The city used to dump the sludge in the ocean, 12 miles offshore, according to Arnold, until Congress banned the practice in 1988. For many years afterwards, the city turned the dried-up dung into fertilizer, but it recently decided the effort was too expensive.

Today, getting rid of the cake costs the city $73 to $77 per ton.

The new boats were partly covered by a federal stimulus grant, but the cost of wastewater treatment is passed on to consumers by way of their water bill.

According to the department’s deputy commissioner for design and construction, the new boats are going into service just in time.

“We’re getting ready for the busiest day of the year,” Vincent Sapienza said, “Black Friday.”

Updated 10:17 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

oowie gooie from Brooklyn says:
Sounds like another missed opportunity to turn water into wine.

Who in the city determined that this valuable fuel source should be deemed waste and turned into a burden on society and the environment.

Reduce, Renew, Reuse!!!
Dec. 1, 2014, 11:34 am
Craig Monk from Texas says:
New York in 1979 commissioned the alleged mob back Merco to dump million of tons of Class B and unprocessed sewage sludge on Sierra Blanca Tx. Today the sewage dump still exist on top of the ground and NY continues to ignore their negligence for Texas.
There is a continuing struggle of citizens to stop this ill conceived practice everywhere. Whether you realize it or not it affects your food and water sources. Why would Whole Foods ban any produce grown on sewage sludge?
Major player in this schema is the EPA, USDA, the CDC and US legislature which pulled the trigger on it in 1990. It has gone too far and now if the EPA was to come clean about contamination millions of acres of farm land the resulting lawsuits by citizens and farmers would exceed the national debt.
Be warned and research what I am saying. Your family and health depend on it.
Dec. 1, 2014, 6:03 pm
Caroline Snyder from New Hampshire says:
To say that these expensive sludge boats are needed " because NYC keeps flushing its toilets" is a bit misleading. If it were only flushing toilets! The fact that sludge generated in the city's 13 treatment plants is the most polluted in the nation has nothing to do with toilets. It is caused because every NY entity connected to a sewer--e.g. hospitals, laundries, metal plating shops, research facilties, dry cleaning establishments--is legally permitted to discharge its hazardous waste into these sewers. Treatment cleans the water; the removed pollutants end up concentrated, in the resulting sludge. What to do with this contaminated waste is a serious problem. The least environmentally damaging solution is to use the ever increasing amount of sludge as a renewable, non fossil fuel source of energy. The technologies exists and are being used in the EU. For more information, see
Dec. 2, 2014, 4:19 pm
OMG from Brooklyn says:
People are making sense and Gov needs to listen!

"Turn water into wine, stop land filling, waste to energy"

This is what we need to be doing. Not bragging about carting away our sludge to be dumped in a landfill somewhere.

Landfilling is not a technology but rather a quick solution leading to a long term problem. One which generation after generation will suffer and pay for.

All waste needs to be dealt with locally and responsibly. As in-our-backyards, we'll only do it right.

Stop destroying our natural resources to extract and transport fossil fuel.

Waste 2 Energy is the infrastructure of the future. And there doing all over the world except here. Wake up USA and find your way. Or else you'll be swimming in it, literally!
Dec. 8, 2014, 9:23 am

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: