Long Island College Hospital legal battle drags on

LICH court drama rages on

The Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

This whole court settlement is out of order!

So claim activists who are suing the state once again, stating that the settlement-outlined scoring process that put developer Fortis Property Group in the negotiation seat to redevelop Long Island College hospital was manipulated by state appointees. The process was supposed to favor developer proposals that kept the Cobble Hill hospital a hospital, but only one of the three top-ranking bids did. Now that the State University of New York has called off talks with two suitors, the state is back to its original, pre-lawsuit pick, a donor to Gov. Cuomo, who controls the university system. The hospital closed on May 22, but the courthouse saga has rambled on and, during an all-day hearing Tuesday, a lawyer for the seven groups suing said once again that a resolution is just over the rise.

“The seminal moment of this case is about to come,” Jim Walden said.

Walden emphasized that the stakes are dire, but expressed hope that the former medical center could still be resurrected.

“If we lose, the chances of a hospital at that campus are dead,” he said.

During the morning portion of the hearing, Judge Johnny Lee Baynes said the community groups, Fortis, and the state were near an agreement, but when court resumed that afternoon there was no mention of a compromise and Walden dove straight into arguing the motion which seeks to have the scoring rearranged to favor fourth-place Prime Healthcare Services, which made a hospital-inclusive pitch, or to start the bidding all over.

“We traded justice for a process,” Walden told the court. “But it was a process in which the other side believed this community was looking for a unicorn.”

Lawyers for the State University of New York and for the state Department of Health explained its appointees’ reported down-voting of hospital-inclusive plans by saying instructions given to the evaluators were necessarily vague and left room for discretion.

“If the criteria were mandatory, why even have evaluators? It could be done by a computer,” said Nicole Gueron, an attorney representing the health department. “That’s not what we set up. We asked smart people to take a hard look.”

The state is continuing its negotiations with the current top bidder Fortis after the state torpedoed talks with Brooklyn Health Partners and Peebles Corporation. The State University of New York is continuing to operate an emergency room at the former site of Long Island College Hospital, though its legal obligation to do so ended May 23. The university system’s website now says the standalone emergency department will remain open until Aug. 30. The department is not accepting ambulances and activists argue that without the attendant services of a hospital it is nothing more than a glorified walk-in clinic.

A pair of deaths in Red Hook over the past two weeks have residents questioning whether the fatalities could have been prevented had the state kept Long Island College Hospital open.

A man died after suffering an asthma attack in his Red Hook Houses apartment on May 21 and it took 32 minutes for paramedics to get him to New York Methodist Hospital, according to FDNY officials. A 14-year-old was fatally struck by the driver of a Bavarian Motor Works car on Hicks Street in Red Hook on Monday morning, according to a report by the New York Post. The boy was also taken to Methodist and died there, the Post wrote.

Fortis president Joel Kestenbaum gave Gov. Cuomo’s re-election campaign $5,000 last November, while his uncle Moshe — who is not a partner in the firm — gave $12,500 in Jan. 2014.

Reach reporter Matthew Perlman at (718) 260-8310. E-mail him at Follow him on Twitter @matthewjperlman.
Updated 10:17 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

David Brown from LES says:
The reality is that the Long Island College Hospital situation is a mess. The obvious solution which would have involved SUNY giving the Hospital and Land to the City in exchange for Debt Service, and keeping a Full Service Hospital open, is something that even Bill De Blasio would not touch with a 10 Foot Pole. Why? Because it makes no economic sense for the City. All the Activists are doing, is making it more unlikely they will get anything close to what they want, and getting even MORE Condos, and less Medical Care (see St Vincent's as an example of this).
June 4, 2014, 9:11 am
Crawford from BayRidge says:
The hospital should be shut down. No demand and too much hosptial capacity in NYC. Sell the land for condos.
June 4, 2014, 9:25 am
Tom from Ft. Greene says:
News reports indicate that in both of the deaths mentioned in this article the primary delay with medical delivery was that ambulances have not been dedicated to Red Hook. Neither had anything to do with the distance to a hospital.

There definitely should be an study about where ambulances are stationed in order to insure rapid service, and an ER at the current LICH site should be accepting ambulances whenever it's appropriate for a free-standing ER.
June 4, 2014, 12:59 pm
Ed from Cobble Hill says:
Question for Crawford of Bay Ridge, should Victory Memorial remain closed and if so why not Beth Isreal and of course Lutherian is next. Plenty of beds in Manhattan.
June 4, 2014, 4:56 pm
will from ocean parkway says:
People like crawford.wouldn't be saying that in a life of death situation because reality will kick in and show that ride across the.bridge during anytime to get them to their wonderful mt. Sinai or Presbyterian hospital, won't save them. Then if something did happen guess what, nobody will get saved.because there is a big useless condo right.there!!!! Makes you think crawford?!
June 4, 2014, 5:34 pm
NANDO from BED STUY says:
In a emergency situation, time is very important. Downtown Brooklyn and the surrounding areas are very populated,and growing.Dumbo Park is across Lich.Condos will not save lives,a hospital is essential, a necessity.Many more lives will be lost unfortunately because of greed and stupidity......
June 5, 2014, 2:12 am

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: