Sections

Red Hook gets G and F train access again

Smith-Ninth subway station reopens

The Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook
Subscribe

Don’t miss our updates:

The long-shuttered Smith-Ninth subway station is finally back in business after two drawn out years of major renovation work.

The sorely missed transit hub on the border of Red Hook and Carroll Gardens that services the F and G lines reopened Friday after a $32-million makeover and months of delays.

“It’s no secret that we all thought this work should have been done sooner and we’re really grateful for the community’s patience. But here we are,” said Fernando Ferrer, the acting chairman of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, at a ribbon-cutting ceremony inside the revamped station Friday.

Rehabilitation of the 80-year-old subway station was originally supposed to be completed in nine months, but fell far behind schedule due to the contractor’s “poor management,” according to an MTA report.

“Insufficient manpower and quality control, and other design issues” contributed to the postponement, the report said.

But now the elevated transportation gateway, which the MTA says is the highest subway station in the world at nearly 88 feet above street level, is up and running better than ever.

Improvements to the station include a new and expanded ground level control house, new lighting, new canopies, rehabilitated stairs and platforms, fully functioning escalators, a new public address system, and a newly installed emergency intercom system.

The station is even adorned with touches of art such as a 14-foot blue tile mosaic by the turnstiles and nautical maps of local bodies of water printed onto 26 windows in the station created by a Red Hook artist.

“This is not your grandpa station that’s for sure,” said Borough President Markowitz just before the first train rolled through the station at 11:05 am to the sound of cheers. “It is just a beautiful rehabilita­tion.”

But transportation-starved Red Hook straphangers who have been without the vital subway station for two arduous years are just glad to have it back in use.

“I really missed it. We needed it the most and now we finally got a good train station in our neighborho­od,” said Red Hook resident Quan Boyd, who added that the condition of the station used to be “disgusting.”

Rider Carolina Cuervo, who lives on the edge of Red Hook, said that without the Smith-Ninth station 15 minutes was added to her commute everyday to Manhattan because she had to walk or take the bus to next nearest stop – the Carroll Street subway station.

“I’m ecstatic,” said Cuervo as she waited for the F train. “I’m so excited, I don’t even know what I’m going to do with my extra 15 minutes – there’s all these possibilit­ies.”

But not all straphangers anticipating the reopening of the station were happy with what they found.

Longtime Red Hook resident Gloria McWilliams, who said she has been diagnosed with lupus that causes immense fatigue, was outraged when she discovered that the multi-million dollar renovation did not include handicap accessibility.

“I’m very disappoint­ed,” she said, adding that she won’t be able to make it up to the platform. “We need elevators and ramps.”

But MTA officials said lifts would have raised the price of the rehab exhorbitantly.

“The design for ADA elevators at this station was financially prohibitive due to the station’s layout,” said MTA spokesman Kevin Ortiz.

Although service has resumed at the station, minor work still has to be done, said MTA officials.

The renovation of the station is part of the agency’s $389 million Culver Viaduct rehabilitation project, which includes the restoration of several other stations, such as the Fourth Avenue-Ninth Street stop.

The closure of the Smith-Ninth subway station precipitated the extension of the G line to Church Avenue, which used to turn around at Smith-Ninth. But the extension, which gave Brooklyn straphangers a one-seat ride between Ditmas Park and Greenpoint without the indignity of going through Manhattan, became so popular the MTA made the extension preeminent.

Reach reporter Natalie Musumeci at nmusumeci@cnglocal.com or by calling (718) 260-4505. Follow her at twitter.com/souleddout.
Updated 10:10 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook
Subscribe

Don’t miss our updates:


Reasonable discourse

scott from park slope says:
$32 million and no elevator?! tell ya what, MTA, pay me $15 million and I'll install 2 elevators. lord, where is the giant boot to kick the collective butt of the MTA into gear and produce meaningful results? $32 million and all they did was slap a discount brand of paint on everything.
April 29, 2013, 9:14 am
JAY from NYC says:
its actually over 41 million spent, and not only no elevator, and not much was done here, seriously, now that is open the State Attorney General needs to launch an investigation into this crap, and into the MTA in general. MTA=Multiple Thefts Agency.
April 29, 2013, 5:22 pm
Seriously? from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:35 pm
Seriously? from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:35 pm
Seriously? from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:36 pm
Seriously? from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:36 pm
Seriously? from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:36 pm
Seriously? from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:36 pm
Seriously from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:36 pm
Seriously? from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:37 pm
Seriously? from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:37 pm
Seriously? from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:37 pm
Seriously? from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:37 pm
Seriously? from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:37 pm
Seriously? from BKNY says:
Not much done? People who don't understand basic structural improvements, are usually the ones who think nothing was done and become critical of what they don't understand. Do you have any idea what happens to steal and concrete over 80 years of being in the elements? It crumbles. So you didn't get a hipstamatic station. My heart bleeds. At least it is not going to crumble under your feet.
April 29, 2013, 5:37 pm
jay from nyc says:
seriously, you posted that b.s. 13 times? What was done was NOT 43 million dollars worth, even the MTA admits that, and that says alot.
The fact that you think this is about hipstamatic something or another shows who does not understand what, and honestly, you need go read a book if the MTA is proving to be smarter than you, that is a REAL bad sign.
April 29, 2013, 8:56 pm
Tal Barzilai from Pleasantville, NY says:
If anyone really wants that subway station to be state of the art, then agree to a fare hike. Maybe that's the reason it wasn't done, especially because a lot of NYers' want the best system but don't want to actually pay for it themselves, which is why they have the rest of us downstaters, especially those of that drive, provide most of the funding. Why should the riders get to use it at such a low price when the tolls are at least double the fares especially with the TZB and VNB tolls covering the bulk of the costs? As for corruption in the MTA, I blame it on the MTA executives, not the TWU, where those are already anti-union are placing the blame on even when there is no proof on them. On a side note, I do have a say in what the MTA does especially when they are a state agency and collect from all of downstate NY, not to mention they did have recent hearings all of the counties the area, not just the ones in NYC itself.
May 1, 2013, 4:42 pm

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: