Cops guard the pews as O’Shea says last Mass at Montserrat

The Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

The Brooklyn Diocese called in a strong show of police force on Sunday outside a beloved Bedford-Stuyvesant chapel that the church hierarchy closed in a controversial move.

Church officials apparently were worried about a large, and angry, crowd attending the last Mass at Our Lady of Montserrat, which the Diocese shuttered for good on Monday in what supporters say is payback for a pastor’s opposition to the Diocese on several political issues.

The renegade priest, Father Jim O’Shea, was on hand for the final rites at the Vernon Street church on Sunday, but parishioners were greeted by three squad cars from the nearby 90th Precinct stationhouse — cops who had been summoned by O’Shea’s superior, Pastor William Chacon, and a representative of the Diocese, sources said.

One of the cops confirmed that a pastor from the church called and parishioners were overheard reprimanding Chacon for calling the police.

“It’s a complete shame that instead of making an appearance and thanking the community, Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio sent the police in fear that people would protest because they know the truth behind the closure is political,” said parishioner Juan Ramos. “[Closing this church] is the ultimate way to stop the community from organizing itself.”

In the past, DiMarzio has said that his decision to close the church last November was based solely on finances and the “long term viability” of the Diocese itself.

With the closing of Montserrat, the Diocese now wants its parishioners to pray at All Saints Church on Throop Avenue, which is seven blocks away. DiMarzio did not comment on the show of police strength, but the Diocese put out a statement on Monday that said it is “deeply aware of the sacrifice that these changes mean for those who worship in these churches.”

“I pray that impacted parishes find comfort in the fact that we are creating a firm foundation for our Diocesan community…for many decades to come,” Monsignor Edward Scharfenberger, who was on the committee that recommended that the church be closed.

In a separate statement, a Diocese spokesman said that the show of police force was not meant as intimidation.

“Community affairs liaisons at the precinct were asked to be in attendance for public safety precautions, not to maintain order,” said the spokesman, Shane Kavanagh.

That did not satisfy some Montserrat faithful, who remain convinced that the decision to close the church was based on O’Shea’s outspoken politics. The father opposed a city plan to rezone the nearby Broadway Triangle and he opposed a state bill that could have prevented some expensive sex-abuse lawsuits against the Catholic Church. Both initiatives were pushed by Assemblyman Vito Lopez (D–Bushwick), a DiMarzio ally, though DiMarzio has denied that the closure of the church had anything to do with O’Shea’s outspokenness.

Rather, the Diocese says that Montserrat has accrued a debt of $395,000 since 2000 and church documents show a deficit of $23,171 in 2010 — though that figure includes inflated utility bills and expenses, such as a secretary’s salary, that does not exist.

Parishioners, many of whom came from other parts of Brooklyn and Queens to visit the church they were baptized and took communion with, mourned the loss of their congregation Sunday with a mix of sadness and resignation.

The building, according to a Diocese spokesman, will be “desacralized” and put on the market in the spring.

“Whatever money gained by the sale of that property is gained in sale by the parish,” said church spokesman Shane Kavanagh. “The plan is to sell it.”

O’Shea’s future is also unclear.

He is being evicted from his residence above the church at the end of February and will not have a regular congregation to lead — but he plans on opening an after-school program across the street for teenagers called “Reconnect.”

Still, dozens of children greeted O’Shea at the end of mass with the same question: “Why are they closing the church?”

“That’s a good question,” said O’Shea.

Updated 5:23 pm, July 9, 2018: An earlier version of this story misattributed a comment. The statement came from Monsignor Edward Scharfenberger.
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

Joey from Clinton Hills says:
oh no, who is protecting the temples on Bedford Ave.?
Feb. 1, 2011, 11:06 am
JoAnne from Prospect Heights says:
Is this an Episcopal church or a Roman Catholic church? I think it must be a Roman Catholic church because it's referred as belonging to the Brooklyn diocese. Roman Catholics segregate Brooklyn by itself. The Episcopals group Brooklyn into the Long Island Diocese.

In any case, it's unclear.
Feb. 2, 2011, 1:28 pm
C from Bed-Stuy says:
This church was a big part of my life growing up and it's a shame that the Brooklyn Diocese is being shady and is hiding their real reason for closing. Show us exactly how we owe that much when before Chacon took over we owed not one penny to anyone. Please explain. Oh and ask Chacon why Monserrate was billed for a secretary it didn't have.

And one thing I'd like to add Father Jim is an amazing man who from the moment he stepped foot in La Monserrate he won all of our hearts, all the children loved him and he was completely dedicated to the church and to it's people. We stand behind him 100% and wish the best for him. It's sad when politics and stupid rivalries can ruin what was a very positive wonderful place for that community. I wish the outcome would be different and it hurts sooo much knowing that the place I used to call my second home now no longer exists. I'm not going to All Saints though cause I really wouldn't want to see that man's face again. Wonder how he sleeps at they all do.

P.s. I wanna thank the nypd who although they should never have been called were only doing their job and they were very courteous and nice to us.
Feb. 2, 2011, 2:26 pm

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: