Sympathetic ‘Gray Lady’ raises big green for PTA embezzler

The Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Need a get out of jail free card? Call the New York Times.

The Gray Lady helped embezzling PTA treasurer Providence Hogan retain her freedom this week — thanks to a gushing column that unleashed a flood of donations to help Hogan repay the $82,000 she stole from her Cobble Hill school.

One month ago, Hogan said that she had just $30,000 in pledges and assets to offer the pilfered parents of PS 29, but after Metropolitan section columnist Ginia Bellafante’s sympathetic story about Hogan was published on Oct. 9, donations poured in.

On Tuesday, Hogan paid back $50,000, and agreed to a repayment schedule consisting of eight quarterly payments of $4,000.

One-third — roughly $16,000 — of that $50,000 payment came from people who were moved by Bellafante’s psychological analysis of the thieving mother, defense attorney Stephen Flamhaft explained.

The rest came from an acquaintance who bought into Hogan’s business, the Providence Day Spa on Atlantic Avenue, and members of B’Nai Avraham on Remsen Street, where Hogan’s husband is a congregant.

“[The Times article] was one of the few instances where she was portrayed sympathetically and it triggered a positive response,” said Flamhaft. “People were about 50-50 on whether Hogan should be punished or receive some kind of compassion. So overall it had an impact.”

The story may have also swayed Supreme Court Justice Suzanne Mondo, who signed off on Hogan’s deal. Flamhaft said Bellafante’s tear-jerker “was discussed” during meetings with Mondo as the plea deal was hammered out.

“It was part of our dialogue,” he said. “That and the other press on the case.”

Mondo could not be reached on Wednesday night, but a spokesman for District Attorney Charles Hynes said that the column was not a factor in the DA’s acceptance of a deal that allows Hogan to make full restitution in two years, instead of the originally propose one.

“The deal was made on the merits of the case,” the spokesman said.

And what a case it was: As treasurer, Hogan had unfettered access to the Henry Street school’s PTA checkbook, and cut checks to herself for fertility treatments and rent on her home and business.

She freely admitted her guilt when she was arrested earlier this year, but rescinded an earlier plea deal offered by Hynes last month, claiming that she couldn’t pay the money back.

Bellafante’s piece depicted Hogan as a woman to be pitied, not punished with a lengthy jail sentence. The story recounted the embezzler’s troubled upbringing and her subsequent depression after her husband lost his job. Hogan told Bellafante that she took the PTA’s money “as a way of staying afloat.”

Bellafante recommended that Hogan not be sent to jail, but rather be allowed to “repay her debt on a realistic timetable” and “perform community service at a school with few of the benefits available at a place like PS 29.”

The story unleashed money and sympathy, but its author said that she never thought the piece was “inappropri­ately sympathetic.”

“The column reflected my larger belief that imprisonment should not be the default response to punishing every type of crime,” she said. “I felt strongly that sending Providence Hogan to jail was not going to make the world a better place.”

Still, Bellafante said she was surprised by the outpouring of support her column generated.

“The response to [the story] from locals was largely critical,” she said. “It wasn’t necessarily evident that she had many sympathizers — not to mention financially generous ones.”

Reach reporter Thomas Tracy at or by calling (718) 260-2525.
Updated 5:27 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

Dave from Park Slope says:
When was the last time The Times wrote a sympathetic piece about a black criminal in East New York? God forbid the white lady from Cobble Hill have to do time.
Nov. 3, 2011, 7:33 am
common sense from bay ridge says:
This scamming —— is going to end up with more $$$ in donations than she stole originally. What a great life lesson for all the students in P.S. 29.
Nov. 3, 2011, 7:43 am
Judah spechal from Beds guy says:
I hate bringing race into this but this really sickens me.
So fed up with the injustice of our justice system. Just freaking fed up. I can't walk down the street w/o police harassing my blk a's then u read this crap.
Nov. 3, 2011, 9:15 am
Frank from WT says:
this reminds me of when tom hagan in the godfather asks if there were any newspapers on the payroll to make the cop that michael killed look dirty..really sad
Nov. 3, 2011, 10:35 am
K. from ArKady says:
Hey Thomas Tracy, you need to track down some of these people who donated money and interview them.
Nov. 3, 2011, 1:01 pm
Blaquelle from B BK says:
Yo, judah - what u be talkin' 'bout willis?
Ha ha ha

Black sistahs gettin' paid!
Dis cheap ho ain't Got nuttin' on a sistah.
You feel mean?
Nov. 4, 2011, 4:17 pm
Cynthia from Clinton Hill says:
Hogan told Bellafante that she took the PTA’s money “as a way of staying afloat. ? well, i guess she had a excuse huh? and The story unleashed money and sympathy? really what newspaper did she get sympathy? not in the Brooklyn paper thats for sure.
Nov. 7, 2011, 10:23 am
Jeanie from Bay Ridge says:
Gee, do I sense a bit of envy here? The Brooklyn Eagle WISHES it was the New York Times? Perhaps your 'investigative skills' should be used in a proper way.

What a sad and stupid article about a sad and stupid woman.

An intelligent use of your time might be tracking down the rest of the PTA blunderers and find out why they got off scott free. Are you really telling us that she did this all by herself and noone else is involved? B.S.
Nov. 8, 2011, 11:46 am
Beverly from Manhattan says:
You really don't hear about communities coming to help troubled members. While some might think this is a bad outcome, I am heartened that people feel strongly enough about this woman to help her. That alone makes me think she must deserve the help.
Nov. 8, 2011, 11:51 am
Really, Bay Ridge Jeanie? from Elsewhere says:
The other so-called PTA 'blunderers' caught the crook, confronted her and immediately notified the police and Department of Education. Ultimately, ProHo's indictment was not just for numerous counts of Grand Larceny, but for covering her tracks through criminal falsification of business documents. Pretty cynical to think that because one thief turns up, every other PTA volunteer who ever entrusted the thieving treasurer with a bale-sale dollar must be corrupt, too. If your house is robbed, does that mean you are a burglar, too?
Nov. 9, 2011, 4:26 pm

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: