March 31, 2010 / Brooklyn news / Park Slope / Meadows of Shame

Swan down! John Boy is dead, but was it poison or murder?

The Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

John Boy Walton, one of the celebrity swans of Prospect Park, has died — setting off a furious battle over whether it was murder … or something even worse!

An animal investigator says it was a classic case of swan-on-swan violence — but waterfowl lovers who visit the park’s lake every day say that John Boy was poisoned by a toxic ecosystem, the result of two weeks of mysterious macabre happenings along the lakefront.

“This poor creature was poisoned; it was not beaten by another swan — that is absurd!” said Ed Bahlman, who observes the swans daily, and has been at the vanguard of an ongoing tale of dead animals, chicken heads, entrails and arson that has kept park-goers riveted for two weeks.

“This swan was not murdered.”

But Bobby Horvath, the licensed wildlife rehabilitator who was called in on Friday to save the ailing bird, says it was likely a homicide.

“We suspect she was beaten up by other swans,” said Horvath, who treated John Boy at his Nassau County home during her final four days. “The bird had good bodyweight — but it had suffered some sort of [blunt] trauma.”

Trauma? Like a murder?

“She had swelling in one leg,” Horvath continud. “Couldn’t walk. The animal was dirty and looked like it was beaten up. This animal’s condition was consistent with other swans that have been beaten up by other adult swans.”

Horvath added that the bird was unresponsive during Horvath’s rehabilitation effort.

But his prognosis did little to silence the conspiracy theories from swan-lovers, who believe that John Boy succumbed to the putrid stew that resulted from dumping by the so-called “Butcher of Prospect Park.”

Several other animals — including a duck, an opossum and turtles — have also turned up dead along the lakefront. Some have been murdered, others might have died of other unnatural causes.

“Maybe the body parts poisoned the water,” said Susan Yuen, who first alerted the authorities to John Boy’s pitiful state. “I don’t know why these animals are dropping dead one by one.” Yuen first noticed John Boy had become unresponsive last Friday.

“Her legs were in an odd position. Her wings were kind of draped in the water,” said Yuen. “She took ill so fast. She should have an autopsy.”

That’s not going to happen — and not only because John Boy has already been cremated, said Horvath, who is also a firefighter who was involved in the eventual release of the coyote that stalked Manhattan last week.

“An animal has to be endangered or threatened for the state to want to test it — or it must be a victim of a crime,” he said. “In my opinion, it didn’t meet any of those criteria.”

Anticipating charges that he is merely part of a cover-up, Horvath added, “No one is telling me what to say. We’re not paid, we’re total volunteers, no one influences my decision or influences what I say.”

For now, all Bahlman and other bird-lovers can do is speculate — at least until the park comes forward with tests of the water in the lake.

Still, Horvath said that poison seemed unlikely.

“Unless the [entrails] have been tampered with, it shouldn’t harm the animals,” he said. “Their stomachs can handle it — and waterfowl don’t go after bones, flesh and chicken heads.”

Horvath said that there is something particularly sad about watching a large, elegant animal like a swan die — especially after having done everything in his power to prevent it.

On Friday, Horvath began a regimen of force feeding John Boy, plus treating her with heat and antibiotics — all to no avail. John Boy went to the big lake in the sky on Monday.

Horvath suggested that the weather, more than poison, is the likely culprit for the wave of animal deaths.

“All of a sudden the weather gets nice, then gets cold again — animals that are already weak or came out of hibernation too early — the weather will kill them,” Horvath said. “And as the weather improves, swans start preparing to nest [and become aggressive]. Its not uncommon, we get injured birds around this time of year.”

And despite Bahlman and others’ insistence, swan-on-swan violence has certainly stalked the lake. It was only last fall that the swans of Prospect Park first appeared in the headlines during a brutal swan war between the Honeybear and Monster clans.

That war appeared to have ended — until last week, perhaps.

Regardless of the cause of death, John Boy stands as the most high-profile animal to die in the midst of the mind-bending mystery that has baffled park officials for the last two weeks.

It all began with a bloody rock by the lake, which appeared to have been used as a chopping block.

Then, smashed turtle shells picked clean of flesh were discovered nearby.

Later, an entire swath of reeds were left a charred wasteland in what appeared to be an arson.

Next, a shocking pile of animal guts and chicken heads were left by the edge of the lake.

Then, the dead animals began appearing.

Updated 5:17 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

Sheila from PLG says:
Let's end the speculation by cleaning up the lake. There have been three reed fires set in the nesting areas and the park personnel has done nothing to clean up the charred areas - There are bottles, diapers and etc especially littering these areas. There are grills that have been thrown into the lake, floating animal remains and other large toxic gallon drums of oil - the lake is poisoned by human stupidity and disregard. I challenge the park personnel to drink the water and then let's see what happens. I applaud Mr Horvath for his desire to help the animals - however, a volunteer rehab person hasn't the knowledge to make an informed diagnosis as to the cause of death of an animal, especially if that person works with a variety of animals. Why doesn't one paid official stand up and say , "Brooklyn deserves better and I am going to dedicate myself to meeting with those concerned and CLEAN UP THE LAKE and then I will protect the lake's inhabitants and come up with a program to educate those who visit the park and redistribute funds from the services that serve non-nature type activities and allot those monies to what a park is NATURE. And I don't mean human nature.
March 31, 2010, 7:21 am
jq from park slope says:
It was that bald ——, Larry David.
March 31, 2010, 2:33 pm
jq from park slope says:
It was that bald a$$hole, Larry David.
March 31, 2010, 2:33 pm
bonita from prospect lefferts garden says:
This was obviously a sick swan from poisoning. Why would the animal people say it was a swan on swan attack? First of all, female swans are not attacked. Secondly, what killed the box turtle found dead near by, a turtle attack??!! And the duck struggling to breath and finally expiring? Letting the animals in the lake die of poisoning is truly shameful. Does any one care in the park? Channel 11 news did an expose saying the park was going to test the water....we'll see if they send it to the same place that said it was another swan that killed John Boy.
March 31, 2010, 9:26 pm
John from Park Slope says:
Mr. Horvath's description of the swan in his care does not seem to match the photos of when he was removed from lake in your article. The cygnet does not look like it was the victim of a swan-on-swan attack.
He also does not appear informed about the deaths of animals in the lake the same week and the contamination of the water.
April 2, 2010, 8:36 am
Jim from Park Slope says:
Anyone think, it could have been the work of a vagrant? or screwed up kids? or some dirty litte cult, trying to draw attention or just somebody sick?? A complete investigation still needs to be done..
Nov. 13, 2010, 1:33 pm

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: