GOP leader endorses Dem McMahon

The Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

How much does the Republican establishment on Staten Island hate former Assemblyman Robert Straniere? So much so that the Republican-Conservative borough president of that island paradise will on Saturday endorse Straniere’s Democratic rival for the long-GOP seat being vacated by Rep. Vito Fossella.

Beep James Molinaro will appear with his choice, Councilman Mike McMahon, at the Staten Island Ferry terminal at 2 pm on Saturday.

The Republican-Conservative Molinaro could not be reached for comment, but his feud with Straniere, who won the Republican nomination for the Fossella seat on Tuesday, goes back to 2004, when Staten Island GOP leaders backed then-Councilman Vincent Ignizio in that year’s primary. Ignizio went on to defeat the assemblyman, who now owns a hot dog restaurant in Manhattan, where he also lives.

Straniere, in a statement, trashed Molinaro as “petty.”

“Sadly, time and time again, we have seen Jim Molinaro blatantly cast aside the fundamental principles of his own Conservative Party for petty, personal vendettas,” the statement said.

“This endorsement is a disservice not only to the Conservative Party and its members, but to all the conservative voters of the 13th Congressional District who want to elect a genuine conservative candidate, like myself, who will truly advance the policies, programs, interests and ideals that I share with the Conservative Party.

“The differences between my 24-year conservative voting record and my opponent’s liberal record couldn’t be more clear,” the statement said.

McMahon blasted back that the Molinaro endorsement had nothing to do with pettiness and everything to do with a good working relationship between the two lawmakers.

“I am proud of the long record Borough President Molinaro and I have fighting for the best interests of Staten Island, and look forward to bringing that fight to Washington for all of the 13th Congressional District,” McMahon said in a statement. “I am honored to have his endorsement, and look forward to the coming challenge to bring real results to Staten Island and Brooklyn for better transit solutions, smarter health care policy and real economic relief for middle class families.”

McMahon’s campaign pointed out that Molinaro endorsed McMahon in both his Council victories.

If this campaign is becoming a slugfest, it started early. On Election Night, McMahon and Straniere didn’t waste any time bashing each other after their easy primary wins on Tuesday night. Straniere linked McMahon to Democratic presidential hopeful Barack Obama and claimed that McMahon would support tax increases. For his part, McMahon reminded voters that Straniere’s own party does not support his run for Congress.

That lack of support remains an oddity, given Straniere’s stated positions on the issues, as he repeated in his Friday afternoon statement:

• “I have consistently voted for tax cuts, where ‘tax-hike Mike’ has voted to raise taxes;

• “I want to reduce the size of government, and keep programs like health care in the private sector, whereas my opponent would expand government’s wasteful and inefficient management of health care programs;

• “I support school vouchers as a way to expand educational opportunities for our children, my opponent does not;

• “I am pro-life. It is not a belief, but a scientific fact, that life begins at conception. … My opponent is pro-abortion; and most importantly,

• “I support the conservative policies and programs of John McCain and Sarah Palin, while my opponent favors the liberal policies of Barack Obama and Joe Biden,” the statement added.

Here is the press release that the McMahon campaign put out in full about Saturday’s stunning political coup:

BP Molinaro To Endorse McMahon for Congress

Standing at the St. George Ferry Terminal, Molinaro to Endorse McMahon as Best Candidate to Fight for Staten Island and 13th CD in Congress

September 12, 2008 – Borough President James Molinaro will announce his endorsement tomorrow, Saturday, September 13th at 2 pm, of Michael McMahon for United States Congress in New York’s 13th Congressional District. The announcement will take place at the St. George Ferry Terminal, which McMahon and Molinaro are working together to build into an economic engine for the North Shore of Staten Island.

WHAT:Molinaro Endorses McMahon for Congress

WHO:Borough President James Molinaro; Council Member Michael McMahon

WHERE:St. George Ferry Terminal

WHEN:Saturday, September 13, 2008

TIME:2:00 pm

Updated 5:08 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

Iggy Blume from Bay Ridge says:
I know your diligent reporters are really very Brooklyn focused, but I expect more from the Editor.

The current Boro Pres of Staten Island is a registered Conservative Party member -- not a Republican. While the two parties have a very close working relationship in Brooklyn, that is not the case in Staten Island. The Conservative Party line in SI is often sold to the incumbent or likely winner and, as such, they have endorsed McMahon often in the past.

Straniere's own response -- and you quoted it -- identifies him as a Conservative! Amusingly, McMahon's does not.

You're probably getting the current Conservative Boro Pres James Molinaro confused with his predecessor Republican Guy Molinari -- a common mistake for a casual observer or J-school dropout. But c'mon!
Sept. 12, 2008, 5 pm

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: