for The Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

On Feb. 25, 1830, when Victor Hugo’s "Hernani" premiered at the Comedie-Francaise, Hugo’s supporters - artists and writers in the Bohemian community - came to blows with defenders of conservative, classical drama.

Today we live in more moderate times. Audience members who did not approve of Richard Maxwell’s staging of Shakespeare’s "Henry IV, Part One" merely walked out of the Brooklyn Academy of Music’s Harvey Theater Tuesday night, so that by the end of the opening-night performance, the theater was perhaps two-thirds full.

Indeed when the play opens with King Henry (Jim Fletcher) and his entourage discussing the military situation in wooden tones and an amateurish style, one wonders - is this an egalitarian introduction? A theatrical gimmick? When will the real actors come on?

As the play went on and on and on, and it became apparent that was it, more and more people left. Those who remained apparently decided the production was a comedy and laughed enthusiastically - often at parts that might have surprised the Bard himself.

Maxwell’s style has been called "deadpan," "hyper-real," "anti-illusionist" and "flat." But Maxwell prefers to call it "objective neutrality."

Many in the audience at BAM probably thought it was just dull.

Theater, according to Maxwell, is more real when the actors don’t pretend what they are doing onstage is real, but rather acknowledge its theatricality. Judging by the result, if Maxwell’s theory is true, junior high school productions are probably the height of "real" theater.

Maxwell’s style may, in fact, be successful with his own work - the Obie award-winning "House" or "Drummer Wanted," but when it comes to Shakespeare, it’s like setting a diamond in plastic. It may be original, but is it worth it?

"Henry IV, Part One" takes off where "Richard II" ends. Bolingbroke, now Henry IV, faces a rebellion led by Henry Percy (Brian Mendes). The king’s son, Prince Hal (Gardiner Comfort) has taken up with the debauched knight Falstaff (Gary Wilmes), who makes fun of duty, responsibility and morality. But when Hal learns about the uprising, he dutifully comes to his father’s aid, helps him defeat his enemies and kills Percy.

This is serious business. It deals with a young man coming of age, the early formation of a king, the father-son relationship and the nature of honor. Even Falstaff, the prankster and parasite, has a masterful command of the English language and delivers some of Shakespeare’s most cutting comments on the nature of bravery.

Living at the height of Elizabethan power, Shakespeare clearly had a sense of history. Maxwell does not. He reduces life-and-death battles to petty quarrels, and momentous events to situation comedy. Even the mock battles make a mockery of human death and power struggles.

Maxwell has assembled a cast of 23 - a mix of actors he’s worked with before, like Wilmes and Fletcher; and newcomers, who range from novices like Peter Guarino, who plays Mortimer, to Jimmie James, who plays Westmoreland, to Paul Viani, a consumer fraud investigator who recently performed with the American Theatre of Actors.

The amateurs can’t act and the professionals are encouraged not to.

Surely Shakespeare deserves something more. And so does the audience.

It’s interesting to note that today "Hernani" is rarely performed and largely unknown even to French audiences. So what was all the fuss about anyway?

Indeed! What is all the fuss about? Maxwell may be a young director (he’s 35) sincerely searching for his own voice. Or he may be a clever self-promoter who came to New York City from the Midwest and figured out a way to impress uptown reviewers. Whichever, it doesn’t much matter to those in the audience who left after the first 10 minutes or, worse yet, those who felt obliged to stay to the end, wasting their money and two hours of their lives.


The New York City Players production of "Henry IV, Part One" continues at the Brooklyn Academy of Music’s Harvey Theater (651 Fulton St. at Lafayette Avenue in Fort Greene) Oct. 2-4, at 7:30 pm. Tickets are $20, $35 and $50. For tickets, call BAM Ticket Services at (718) 636-4100 or by visiting the Web site at

Updated 4:00 pm, November 10, 2010
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: